The Strange Silence of the Past

The Strange Silence of the Past: A History of Jewish Lynchings – Part 1

Leo Frank

Leo Max Frank ~ 1913

On a hot August day in 1915 a slight man was dragged from a car, a month old slash across his throat raw, red, and rebloodied.  He was wearing a nightshirt and an undershirt with a piece of brown canvas tied around his waist like a skirt.  His hands were handcuffed before him and his ankles were tied.  A brand new manila rope was placed around his neck and tied in such a way as to force his head back.  The rope was thrown over a tree branch and he was hauled up and hung in the fresh light of a day that was still new.  A crowd of men, women and children, by some estimates 6000 strong, arrived on cars, on horses, and on foot to gawk at the unnatural art of the 28 men who had commenced its creation: a man whose head now tilted upwards sharply as though he were imploring heaven.  The man was so small in stature he seems almost childlike next to the grim but smug faces of his murderers who peer from the photographs back through time, daring us to judge them.

The man who died by lynching was Leo Max Frank, a wealthy Jewish factory superintendent, convicted of assaulting and strangling a young girl, Mary Phagan, who had worked at the factory he managed.  He was almost certainly innocent, and I won’t rehash the details of her murder here.  I will mention that some of the men who lynched him included former governors, mayors, sheriffs, police, a superior court judge, business owners, lawyers, a banker, and even a doctor.  Not the hoi poi one would usually think of as a lynch mob.

Mary Phagan

Mary Phagan, age 13 ~ 1913

Many sources (CNN, Dallas News, article by a law professor, even a Jewish History website) claim he was the only Jewish man lynched on American soil, but not only was he not the only Jewish victim of lynching, he wasn’t even the first that year.  That horrific honor went to a Jewish journalist named Albert Bettelheim, who was convicted of murder and lynched just two days before Leo Frank, on August 15th, also in Georgia.  This is, coincidentally, the same day in 1868 when another Jewish man, S.A. Bierfield, an owner of a dry goods store in Tennessee, and his black employee, Lawrence Bowman, were also lynched by the KKK.  Apparently, S.A. Bierfield was a supporter of Reconstruction and had the audacity to sell to both black and white customers. I’ve seen references to two other Jews lynched in the 1890s but details are hard to come by.

I never intended to become an accidental lay authority on Jewish lynchings in America.  I came about the information regarding Leo Frank unintentionally in my quest to understand my past.  And what I found had profound implications on the lives of my great-grandmother, Jessie, (whom I’m named for) her husband, Jacob, and my grandfather, Edward.

It started several years ago as a Christmas gift to my father (my mother is Catholic and the tradition has stuck) who was very close with his grandmother.  He laughingly told me on more than one occasion that Jessie was the only adult in his life that never hit him.  He spoke of her in gentle terms and it was clear his deep affection for her remained unchanged from his boyhood.  Her death when he was nine meant he never really knew her history or who she was as a real person.  He had some vague tales of his grandfather living in Atlanta, Georgia until the age of eight, and then coming back to Kings County, Brooklyn for unknown reasons.

It was a mystery.

I love mysteries.

I was hooked.

The idea of learning more about my namesake was exciting.  The Internet and sites like ancestry.com make it ridiculously easy these days, compared to having to go to actual locations and sift through a morass of old paperwork yourself.  If you even know where to look.  If you’re lucky enough to have full names that are correct.

Jessie and Jacob on their Wedding Day, New York, 1903

Jessie and Jacob on their Wedding Day, New York, 1903

The idea of a Jewish family living in Atlanta in the early 1900s seemed like a bizarre tale where half of the facts must be wrong.  Both Jessie and Jacob were foreign born, most likely from Russia, but there’s some indication that Jessie may have come from the Republic of Georgia originally.  They arrived before 1900 during an enormous influx of Jewish immigrants fleeing Russian persecution.  Between 1848 and 1904 the number of Jews in New York went from around 15,000 to close to 700,000.

In a city swimming with other Jews it’s unlikely that Jessie and Jacob knew Leo Frank personally, although they were all around the same age and only lived about a mile and a half apart.  In an area like Kings County one mile might as well have been a hundred.  Jessie and Jacob appear to have met at a cigar factory.  Jessie’s sister, Rebecca, had married Morris Chigorinsky, a Russian Jew and the founder of American Leaf Tobacco and so they may have both been working for him.  They married in Brooklyn, NY in 1903.  Jacob was 23 and Jessie, 21.  Four years later my grandfather was born and in 1911 they moved from Kings County, Brooklyn to Atlanta, Georgia and opened up a grocery.

It seemed strange to me that they would leave their familiar community of New York and head south, but it turns out that Atlanta was initially very welcoming to the Jewish community.  Some of the seeds of the anti-Semitism that flourished in the wake of the Leo Frank trial can be found as early at 1845 when Jews made up just 1% of Atlanta’s 2572 residents, but owned 10% of the real estate.

Starting around 1881 a large influx of Russian Jews relocated from the North and started small businesses.  The Russian Jews were somewhat at odds with the German Jews who had been in Atlanta longer and were more established and less conspicuous.  One of these German born Jews was the uncle of Leo Max Frank who invited him to interview for a position at his business, the National Pencil Company, in 1907.  After training in Germany for nine months he relocated to Atlanta in 1908, becoming the superintendent of the factory and eventually buying enough shares to become co-owner.

Women Who Mourn Mary Phagan

Considering the separation of German and Russian Jews in Atlanta at that time and the fact that my great-grandparents were ardent atheists it is unlikely the Shookoffs and the Franks intermingled.  But they probably knew of each other.  After all, Frank’s sister married a German cigar maker who was also based in New York, similar to Jessie’s sister.  Atlanta’s Jewish population at that time was around 4200 to 4500, far smaller than that of New York, making it more likely that they might frequent the same stores or restaurants.

The Jewish community rallied around Leo Max Frank following his arrest and conviction in 1913 and suffered the consequences.  Many of their stores were boycotted, threatening their livelihoods.  What other specific consequences they suffered is unknown, because I’ve been unable to locate any sources on the Internet that specify the exact atmosphere of Atlanta at that time.  Was there more than boycotting?  Was there violence?  Atlanta’s crime rate at the time was quite high, so it stands to reason that there may have been incidents of hate crimes.  If there were I can’t find any references to them on the web. Suffice to say, the tensions and the fear must have been overwhelming for the Jewish community.

On the other hand it’s not hard to see why so many Southerners were incensed by the case, which had so much to do with North vs. South and rich vs. poor, not just Baptist vs. Jew.  The anti-Semitism seems to have been an expression of the deep resentment regarding the exploitation of Southern women in the factories that were springing up in Atlanta, many of which had sweatshop conditions.  The National Pencil Company was no exception.  And yes, Leo Frank himself, and his lawyers, were quite racist, viciously so during his trial.  An apologist might argue that with his life at stake he couldn’t afford to quibble over niceties.  I myself wonder what the value of such a life is when bought with that kind of currency . . .

Marietta Georgia

Marietta, Georgia

Part 2

8 thoughts on “The Strange Silence of the Past

  1. Very interesting Jessie. Have you used rootsweb.com for research? It has a lot of the same info as ancestry.com but it’s free. I have LOTS of info on your Dewey ancestors and I’d love to discuss it with you.

    Like

    • I haven’t tried rootsweb. The nice thing with ancestry is that it does allow searching of international databases (for a price of course!). I don’t know if rootsweb does that. I’ve basically hit a wall in researching my Jewish ancestors: the poor didn’t tend to leave much of a trace. On Andrew’s side, through one of his grandmothers, I was able to go back over 1500 years and found out his 55th grandfather was one of the first kings of Britain. Once you hit royalty there’s lots of records.

      I don’t know that much about the Deweys or the Mohans but I would love to! Especially the Deweys that first came to America several hundred years ago. And definitely more about the Mohans and other Irish relatives.

      🙂

      Like

      • Well, Jessica, you and Andrew might be cousins (several hundred times removed)? We also go back to the kings – of England, Ireland and Scotland. Vikings also (with very interesting names, such as Skull-Crusher), Goths (the REAL kind), Romans, too. Because there were several famous Deweys (all related to Thomas the Settler who came to the US around 1633), it isn’t hard to trace back. I have literally thousands of branches on the tree and it’s very hard to organize. Next time I get into genealogy mode, I will send you more info (once I go there it’s weeks before I come out of it, but right now I don’t have time to go there – if you know what I mean).

        Like

      • I do understand! The last time I was ancestor diving I didn’t come up for air for three weeks. My children were starting to forget what I looked like.

        I know you’re busy, so when you get a chance you can email me (jessicagajda@gmail.com) and I’ll send you a list of Andrew’s direct ancestry starting with his first noble ancestor (his 13th great-grandmother) to his 51st great-grandfather, Cerdic, King of Wessex.

        I’ve thought about how these things could be better organized. I’ve focused mainly on direct ancestors, because otherwise it gets unwieldy, but I kind of feel that leaves a lot out. I’m sure it will take a lifetime to sort out!

        Also, when you get a chance, if I could get a list of the direct line from Thomas the Settler to present day? If it’s not too difficult. If it is, no worries. And it doesn’t have to be anytime soon. I know how things get!

        🙂

        Like

  2. I have to confess that after reading the opening snippet, I decided to pass on reading the entire post. Three or four times I did that. But I just finished it now and am fascinated, and I look forward to part 2.

    Like

    • Thank you, Maggie. I decided to make the title really represent what the essay was about so people could steer clear if was something they didn’t want to read. It’s a tough issue. It was very draining to research and to write. Thanks for deciding to read it anyway!

      🙂

      Like

  3. It is fascinating that just a little attention, a mere incentive may uncover stories so dramatic, even tragic and yet so thrilling – of course not ‘thrilling’ in the B-class action movie style. My grandmother’s brother has managed to trace back our roots back to the 17th century, but whenever I get the chance I keep asking her about her memories. They’re just priceless.
    And once again I just MUST congratulate you on your writing style: focused and intellectual. Rumour has it 98% of blogs are worthless, but you are in the minority, Jessica!

    Liked by 1 person

  4. describing the result of the hanging as “unnatural art” was appropriately surprising and horrid.

    This sentence got me thinking: “Some of the seeds of the anti-Semitism that flourished in the wake of the Leo Frank trial can be found as early at 1845 when Jews made up just 1% of Atlanta’s 2572 residents, but owned 10% of the real estate.” Could this be comparable to the current situation of 1% of the population owning 99% of the world’s resources (or whatever the actual figures are)? Might I not be alone in heading toward anti-major-corporatism? Does giving a corporation human rights deter lynching corporations? Are we so swayed to believe that our livelihood depends on the livelihood of major corporations, that we don’t dare to harm a hair on their “heads”?

    My genealogy research is one of the ingredients in the pavement of my road to blogging. I am writing a fictional autobiography of my grandmother’s grandmother. Like you, I am fascinated by what I can find about the areas where she lived and events that took place during that time.

    Since I began the fictional autobiography, I found other writers who did something similar. I am especially captivated by the ones who let their characters write the story, and found afterward uncanny similarities between what they wrote, and little-known details that actually happened. If you want to know more about Leo Max Frank, you might want to do something similar; take off on “what if” trails. You know how it works: some paths lead you along, while others go nowhere.

    Hooray for all that you have accomplished with your research! I worked with ancestry.com when I could access it for free through my local library system. Now, I use dozens of free sources of info. I’m a purist about only relying on properly documented resources (wills, deeds, registrations and such), but the undocumented claims on genealogy forums give me possibilities to consider following.

    Great photos!

    I took a liking to GenBox (I think that’s the name) software early on, for keeping track of my research. I can’t imagine doing it any other way. Unfortunately, the GenBox developer got a “real” job, so it’s no longer available or supported. I don’t know anything anymore about the other software available.

    I’m on to Part 2…

    Like

I Love Your Feedback!

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s